tricks for eliminating pops on ID starts in montage

All topics on WaveLab 9 and WaveLab Elements 9
taylor12k
Junior Member
Posts: 127
Joined: Tue Jul 19, 2016 4:55 pm
Contact:

tricks for eliminating pops on ID starts in montage

Post by taylor12k » Thu Jan 10, 2019 5:05 pm

got a pesky clicking montage this morning. it's a single audio file split with a half dozen ID splice points. they sound fine when playing from WaveLab, but when i make a DDP and audition in a DDP player a couple of them have clicks at the beginning.

same with iTunes and other players, but sometimes different tracks have clicks depending on the playback program.

beyond "quantize cd markers" and manually moving around and trying different spots, is there a tried-and-true method for finding spots that won't cause clicks?

it's a pain to nudge a marker, quantize, export DDP, play, repeat... and i don't seem to be anywhere closer to eliminating the clicks...

thanks for any tips!

S-EH
Member
Posts: 356
Joined: Sat Dec 18, 2010 12:47 pm
Contact:

Re: tricks for eliminating pops on ID starts in montage

Post by S-EH » Thu Jan 10, 2019 5:21 pm

Hi!

It's very difficult to know your audio and where and why it clicks
but if's a CD track start then if it start at zero crossing and not to short
200-400 ms before audio starts then it should not click!
but if the CD track start audio is not at zero crossing and to short start up time
yes it likely to click and this depends on player(s) soft or hardware

but its hard to guess if you don't have the CD/audio to hear and see in the DAW

someone else....

regards S-EH
RME Fireface 800, WaveLab, Cubase...

User avatar
Justin P
Senior Member
Posts: 2462
Joined: Fri Aug 12, 2011 12:49 pm
Location: Milwaukee, WI USA
Contact:

Re: tricks for eliminating pops on ID starts in montage

Post by Justin P » Thu Jan 10, 2019 5:39 pm

Have you checked your rendered DDP back in WaveLab or a DDP Player? Or checked your rendered WAVs in a new montage when butted up against each other with no space added between the clips? Do you hear the clicks there?

I think the best you can do is make sure your master WAVs (and DDP of course) do not click when playing from one song to the next. Anything beyond that is coming very player dependent now.

Are you running any plugins when rendering your master WAVs? I've found that many plugins are not sample accurate at the start of renders so what I do is render the entire montage as one file in a single pass. So in other words, render the Whole Montage as a single file. Use the render settings to have WaveLab create a new montage on the resulting render to carry over all your marker info etc. so everything else is the same.

Then when I insert a dither plugin and render WAVs as each track, I can get seamless transitions.

When I try to render gapless/seamless tracks as WAV from the montage with any plugins (other than dither and light duty stuff), usually plugin processing (3rd party EQ, compressors, limiters etc.) will cause little clicks and pops but you can avoid this by doing a single render to print all the FX to a new file. You could print the dither too if you don't plan to make any more changes to the audio but I do not print the dither because I often have to produce different sample rates and dither after that.
https://www.mysteryroommastering.com/https://www.justincarlperkins.com/
https://www.facebook.com/groups/WaveLab/

iMac Pro 3.0GHz 10-Core • 64GB RAM • SSD for OS and audio • MacOS 10.14.6
Mac Mini 3.2 GHz Intel Core i7 (6-Core) • 32GB RAM • SSD for OS and audio • MacOS 10.14.6

RME AES HDSPe, MUTEC MC-3+ Smart Clock USB, Grace m905, Grace m900

bob99
Senior Member
Posts: 2526
Joined: Fri Jan 07, 2011 2:49 am
Contact:

Re: tricks for eliminating pops on ID starts in montage

Post by bob99 » Thu Jan 10, 2019 8:02 pm

taylor12k wrote:
Thu Jan 10, 2019 5:05 pm
got a pesky clicking montage this morning. it's a single audio file split with a half dozen ID splice points. they sound fine when playing from WaveLab, but when i make a DDP and audition in a DDP player a couple of them have clicks at the beginning. same with iTunes and other players, but sometimes different tracks have clicks depending on the playback program.beyond "quantize cd markers" and manually moving around and trying different spots, is there a tried-and-true method for finding spots that won't cause clicks? it's a pain to nudge a marker, quantize, export DDP, play, repeat... and i don't seem to be anywhere closer to eliminating the clicks...thanks for any tips!
imo It's a continuing issue with no perfect solutions except trying in different cd players (which will all play slightly different). Finding zero crossings in both channels exactly at automatic quantized cd frames is a chore at best, and then is often negated by the different cd players playback anyway. Maybe settle for the best compromises. I wonder what they did about zero crossings before music computers, when zero crossings *didn't exist*. Just plain old audition, I guess. There were certainly live continuous cd's and cd's with track crossfades before that.
Last edited by bob99 on Fri Jan 11, 2019 4:02 am, edited 3 times in total.

bob99
Senior Member
Posts: 2526
Joined: Fri Jan 07, 2011 2:49 am
Contact:

Re: tricks for eliminating pops on ID starts in montage

Post by bob99 » Thu Jan 10, 2019 8:25 pm

You could try micro fades creating zero crossings exactly at cd frames, like one user in the past. Not sure how effective that is in all cases though, or when it becomes audible.
Last edited by bob99 on Mon Jan 14, 2019 9:32 am, edited 1 time in total.

taylor12k
Junior Member
Posts: 127
Joined: Tue Jul 19, 2016 4:55 pm
Contact:

Re: tricks for eliminating pops on ID starts in montage

Post by taylor12k » Thu Jan 10, 2019 8:34 pm

thanks for all the feedback and help.. a few replies:

- no, no plug ins on the render, except for the dithering to 16 from 24

- i haven't tried re-importing the renders into a new montage to see if they click when i line them back up

- the DDP player is clicking two of the cuts.. so i'm still hesitant to send to the client .. i am aware that different playback devices may click or not.. but if my own DDP is, then i don't want to send it.

sounds like i need to keep moving the splice points around to try different places..!

User avatar
Justin P
Senior Member
Posts: 2462
Joined: Fri Aug 12, 2011 12:49 pm
Location: Milwaukee, WI USA
Contact:

Re: tricks for eliminating pops on ID starts in montage

Post by Justin P » Thu Jan 10, 2019 8:49 pm

You should be able to produce seamless WAV renders from the montage, especially if no plugins are used. I haven't tested with all dither plugins but even with Goodhertz Good Dither I can do it. When I introduce other more intense plugins, then the problems come in which is why I do a full render before dividing up into tracks. I got this idea when I was troubleshooting a similar case and the DDP didn't have the clicks but the WAVs did. This is because a DDP render is technically one long render so I realized that if I process my WAVs in that way, the problems went away. The "Create Montage From Resulting File" option makes quick work of all this.

Are you using CD Tracks Splice markers at these points to ensure there is no space between the end and start markers? I never using anything other than CD Track Splice Markers other than the very first and very last marker of the project of course.

Maybe also try without your dither plugin just to rule that out.
https://www.mysteryroommastering.com/https://www.justincarlperkins.com/
https://www.facebook.com/groups/WaveLab/

iMac Pro 3.0GHz 10-Core • 64GB RAM • SSD for OS and audio • MacOS 10.14.6
Mac Mini 3.2 GHz Intel Core i7 (6-Core) • 32GB RAM • SSD for OS and audio • MacOS 10.14.6

RME AES HDSPe, MUTEC MC-3+ Smart Clock USB, Grace m905, Grace m900

taylor12k
Junior Member
Posts: 127
Joined: Tue Jul 19, 2016 4:55 pm
Contact:

Re: tricks for eliminating pops on ID starts in montage

Post by taylor12k » Fri Jan 11, 2019 3:11 pm

yes, i'm using splice markers.. and just the built in wavelab dither...

i'll try without it now....

Justin P wrote:
Thu Jan 10, 2019 8:49 pm
You should be able to produce seamless WAV renders from the montage, especially if no plugins are used. I haven't tested with all dither plugins but even with Goodhertz Good Dither I can do it. When I introduce other more intense plugins, then the problems come in which is why I do a full render before dividing up into tracks. I got this idea when I was troubleshooting a similar case and the DDP didn't have the clicks but the WAVs did. This is because a DDP render is technically one long render so I realized that if I process my WAVs in that way, the problems went away. The "Create Montage From Resulting File" option makes quick work of all this.

Are you using CD Tracks Splice markers at these points to ensure there is no space between the end and start markers? I never using anything other than CD Track Splice Markers other than the very first and very last marker of the project of course.

Maybe also try without your dither plugin just to rule that out.

User avatar
Justin P
Senior Member
Posts: 2462
Joined: Fri Aug 12, 2011 12:49 pm
Location: Milwaukee, WI USA
Contact:

Re: tricks for eliminating pops on ID starts in montage

Post by Justin P » Fri Jan 11, 2019 3:45 pm

taylor12k wrote:
Fri Jan 11, 2019 3:11 pm
yes, i'm using splice markers.. and just the built in wavelab dither...

i'll try without it now....

Justin P wrote:
Thu Jan 10, 2019 8:49 pm
You should be able to produce seamless WAV renders from the montage, especially if no plugins are used. I haven't tested with all dither plugins but even with Goodhertz Good Dither I can do it. When I introduce other more intense plugins, then the problems come in which is why I do a full render before dividing up into tracks. I got this idea when I was troubleshooting a similar case and the DDP didn't have the clicks but the WAVs did. This is because a DDP render is technically one long render so I realized that if I process my WAVs in that way, the problems went away. The "Create Montage From Resulting File" option makes quick work of all this.

Are you using CD Tracks Splice markers at these points to ensure there is no space between the end and start markers? I never using anything other than CD Track Splice Markers other than the very first and very last marker of the project of course.

Maybe also try without your dither plugin just to rule that out.
Strange. I can pretty reliably get smooth gapless transitions on my master WAVs and of course DDP when doing this.

Have you tried loading the WAVs and/or DDP back into WaveLab to verify and visualize what is going on to produce the clicks at the transition points? There are also some recent reports of the Steinberg DDP Player not playing nice with gapless tracks so I'd check by loading back into a new WaveLab montage, and make sure you're using a trusted DDP Player like HOFA or Sonoris when checking outside of WaveLab.
https://www.mysteryroommastering.com/https://www.justincarlperkins.com/
https://www.facebook.com/groups/WaveLab/

iMac Pro 3.0GHz 10-Core • 64GB RAM • SSD for OS and audio • MacOS 10.14.6
Mac Mini 3.2 GHz Intel Core i7 (6-Core) • 32GB RAM • SSD for OS and audio • MacOS 10.14.6

RME AES HDSPe, MUTEC MC-3+ Smart Clock USB, Grace m905, Grace m900

kywoman
New Member
Posts: 39
Joined: Tue Mar 15, 2016 3:58 pm
Contact:

Re: tricks for eliminating pops on ID starts in montage

Post by kywoman » Wed Aug 21, 2019 2:11 am

Bumping this because I've been bumping my head against the desk for most of today trying to figure out, in vain, how to stop pops clicks ticks whatever from being introduced when rendering from a montage. This is happening in a file that has some crossfades in them, fade-ins on the new parts. I only have one plugin, DMG Limitless, on Effects>Output, no other plugs anywhere. All Track IDs are Splices. If I render the tracks from the montage as individual files, I get a pop click tick at the beginning and end of some resultant files. If I render a single full track, create montage from resulting file and carry over markers, I get no pops in the single large file. However, I still get the pop introduced when rendering individual tracks from this new file.
There is no significant DC offset (RX shows it to be < +0.023 on either channel). The track IDs are quantized to CD Frames. I've searched for zero crossings. As previous threads have pointed out, there are rarely good places where both channels are at a zero crossing. I've tried a variety of options, redrawing one or both channels from a variety of locations, to be at zero at the Splice. It will happen on the same tracks, regardless of rendering format (wavs, mp3s, or aacs) at native Fs and float bit or with Resampling and MBit+ dither.

Is there any solution for this?

It's maddening, and I'm hoping there's something better than the microfades (orangesomething, forget username, sorry) tried. That seems like a crazy workaround; it would be nice not to have to silence the audio by hand to resolve these ticks introduced by the IDs!
bob99 wrote:
Thu Jan 10, 2019 8:25 pm
You could try micro fades creating zero crossings exactly at cd frames, like one user in the past. Not sure how effective that is in all cases though, or when it becomes audible.
Also, Feature Request! Boy would it be nice if the 'find nearest zero crossing' function was expanded - e.g., I could click it and continue to move forward or backward in time to each next zero crossing. Unless I'm missing something, I have to move cursor from present zero crossing to a spot that's closer to the next one, which isn't convenient to say the least, given I'm asking the program to find the zero crossing. You see the catch-22, right? I get that it's useful for just refining to exact point, but I think it would be far more powerful and helpful to have an expanded function with this.

Does anyone have a useful shortcut for checking each file in RX (or WL, spectral or wavelet view), where one can drag a batch of files in, and they all open to a zoomed in beginning or end of file, in order to easily/quickly see if a tick has been introduced?

User avatar
Justin P
Senior Member
Posts: 2462
Joined: Fri Aug 12, 2011 12:49 pm
Location: Milwaukee, WI USA
Contact:

Re: tricks for eliminating pops on ID starts in montage

Post by Justin P » Wed Aug 21, 2019 3:11 am

This issue isn't exclusive to WaveLab but I guarantee this will solve your problem, it's how I render every montage, overlaps or not, just to be safe. You don't have to do any micro-fades or anything weird. I don't think you have a zero crossing issue. While zero crossings are ideal for when skipping to a track, you can put the track ID in the middle of the biggest kick drum ever and avoid a glitch when played straight through if rendered properly.

When you're happy with the sound, marker placement etc, render the Whole Montage as one long file to lock in all plugin processing. I personally save it as a floating point WAV to account for additional sample rate conversion and other flexibilities but either way, render the Whole Montage as a single file.

There are render options that will create a montage from the resulting file, and copy over all the markers, CD-Text, etc. Everything is the same as the source montage, but the processing is locked in so no plugins (other than dither) are needed.

From here, you can render seamless WAVs of each CD Track. I can even do this with a dither plugin inserted, I'm guessing because it's less CPU demeaning than a limiter.

What I can't account for is if you're using the Resampler in the global master section but as long as there are no plugins involved with the track by track render, it should be OK. Even Goodhertz Good Dither is OK to use here.

If you do need to get to a lower sample rate, I suggest using an external program to downsample the continuous render with the processing locked in, resample to the desired sample rate, use the Custom Montage Copy feature to create a new montage from the resampled file, and all is good.

How I double check for gapless/seamless WAV rendering is to make a new montage, load in the WAVs with 0 seconds spacing between them, and play the files. If you don't hear a tick or pop as it plays from one WAV to the next, all is good.

Let me know if any clues in there help to get it sorted out.
https://www.mysteryroommastering.com/https://www.justincarlperkins.com/
https://www.facebook.com/groups/WaveLab/

iMac Pro 3.0GHz 10-Core • 64GB RAM • SSD for OS and audio • MacOS 10.14.6
Mac Mini 3.2 GHz Intel Core i7 (6-Core) • 32GB RAM • SSD for OS and audio • MacOS 10.14.6

RME AES HDSPe, MUTEC MC-3+ Smart Clock USB, Grace m905, Grace m900

kywoman
New Member
Posts: 39
Joined: Tue Mar 15, 2016 3:58 pm
Contact:

Re: tricks for eliminating pops on ID starts in montage

Post by kywoman » Wed Aug 21, 2019 5:44 am

This happens using your workflow of rendering with the output plugin into a new montage copying all IDs CD-Text etc. (and like your idea for a few reasons, faster rendering of individual filesets vs. each individual fileset having to run through limiter plugin, less load on processor for fileset = greater peace of mind, etc.). Unfortunately, the tick is present on the renders of tracks from either the old or new montage. Yet it is *not* on the continuous wav created by the initial montage where the final limiter is. So I think it's the Splice IDs that are at play, and the ticks are at the beginning and ending of tracks that have xfades in the initial montage. In theory, there's no xfade on the new montage, as it's just one file at 32 float. But nevertheless, tick is still there. This is the first time I've experienced this in years of WL, where I imagine I've placed Splices at non-zero crossings at some point without issue...

As for resampling, tick persists regardless of Resampler in global master section on or off, and the off via bypass of just resampler or global master bypassed. I've not tried sample rate conversion via external app like RX< but tick is occurring without any resampling.

It's a headscratcher. Headbanger. Thanks Justin, as always.

bob99
Senior Member
Posts: 2526
Joined: Fri Jan 07, 2011 2:49 am
Contact:

Re: tricks for eliminating pops on ID starts in montage

Post by bob99 » Wed Aug 21, 2019 9:23 am

kywoman wrote:
Wed Aug 21, 2019 2:11 am
I only have one plugin, DMG Limitless, on Effects>Output, no other plugs anywhere.
Does it happen if you remove Limitless, or replace it with something else? You say you can see the tick in the rendered files? (it's more than just a transient playback problem?).

User avatar
Justin P
Senior Member
Posts: 2462
Joined: Fri Aug 12, 2011 12:49 pm
Location: Milwaukee, WI USA
Contact:

Re: tricks for eliminating pops on ID starts in montage

Post by Justin P » Wed Aug 21, 2019 1:07 pm

I'm going to post a sample session here to hopefully help you but in the mean time, it's a long shot, but do you have this setting turned on?:
Attachments
Screen Shot 2019-08-21 at 7.05.47 AM.png
(159.55 KiB) Not downloaded yet
https://www.mysteryroommastering.com/https://www.justincarlperkins.com/
https://www.facebook.com/groups/WaveLab/

iMac Pro 3.0GHz 10-Core • 64GB RAM • SSD for OS and audio • MacOS 10.14.6
Mac Mini 3.2 GHz Intel Core i7 (6-Core) • 32GB RAM • SSD for OS and audio • MacOS 10.14.6

RME AES HDSPe, MUTEC MC-3+ Smart Clock USB, Grace m905, Grace m900

User avatar
Justin P
Senior Member
Posts: 2462
Joined: Fri Aug 12, 2011 12:49 pm
Location: Milwaukee, WI USA
Contact:

Re: tricks for eliminating pops on ID starts in montage

Post by Justin P » Wed Aug 21, 2019 1:41 pm

OK, here is a little sample session I came up with:
https://www.dropbox.com/s/swgd1c20ql83w ... r.zip?dl=1

There is a READ ME file in the zip with all the audio but I'll post it here too for easy access.

Hopefully it helps you get to the bottom of what's going wrong on your end, but gapless/seamless render is possible in WaveLab, or I wouldn't be using it.
Attachments
Seamless Render READ ME.zip
(1.99 KiB) Downloaded 22 times
https://www.mysteryroommastering.com/https://www.justincarlperkins.com/
https://www.facebook.com/groups/WaveLab/

iMac Pro 3.0GHz 10-Core • 64GB RAM • SSD for OS and audio • MacOS 10.14.6
Mac Mini 3.2 GHz Intel Core i7 (6-Core) • 32GB RAM • SSD for OS and audio • MacOS 10.14.6

RME AES HDSPe, MUTEC MC-3+ Smart Clock USB, Grace m905, Grace m900

kywoman
New Member
Posts: 39
Joined: Tue Mar 15, 2016 3:58 pm
Contact:

Re: tricks for eliminating pops on ID starts in montage

Post by kywoman » Wed Aug 21, 2019 3:29 pm

Thanks for session, I'll check it out today. As for reset of plugin, and to this issue more in general, I want to make sure you understand that:
Justin P wrote:
Wed Aug 21, 2019 1:41 pm
gapless/seamless render is possible in WaveLab, or I wouldn't be using it.
This isn't the problem.
If I render a single full track, create montage from resulting file and carry over markers, I get no pops in the single large file.
I'm not having an issue rendering a single file from a montage with crossfades etc. But when I use that new file in the new montage to render all regions / CD tracks, I get the same result as if I did so in the original montage; a tick in the same place, which is indeed visible in RX spectrally in addition to audible playback.

User avatar
Justin P
Senior Member
Posts: 2462
Joined: Fri Aug 12, 2011 12:49 pm
Location: Milwaukee, WI USA
Contact:

Re: tricks for eliminating pops on ID starts in montage

Post by Justin P » Wed Aug 21, 2019 3:44 pm

kywoman wrote:
Wed Aug 21, 2019 3:29 pm
But when I use that new file in the new montage to render all regions / CD tracks, I get the same result as if I did so in the original montage; a tick in the same place, which is indeed visible in RX spectrally in addition to audible playback.
This shouldn't be the case though, that's why I'm hoping my example montages, files, and render presets help you out.

As you can see and hear in the rendered test files of each CD Track which simulate what would be the final master files, there is no tick audible or visible.
https://www.mysteryroommastering.com/https://www.justincarlperkins.com/
https://www.facebook.com/groups/WaveLab/

iMac Pro 3.0GHz 10-Core • 64GB RAM • SSD for OS and audio • MacOS 10.14.6
Mac Mini 3.2 GHz Intel Core i7 (6-Core) • 32GB RAM • SSD for OS and audio • MacOS 10.14.6

RME AES HDSPe, MUTEC MC-3+ Smart Clock USB, Grace m905, Grace m900

bob99
Senior Member
Posts: 2526
Joined: Fri Jan 07, 2011 2:49 am
Contact:

Re: tricks for eliminating pops on ID starts in montage

Post by bob99 » Wed Aug 21, 2019 6:24 pm

kywoman wrote:
Wed Aug 21, 2019 3:29 pm
I'm not having an issue rendering a single file from a montage with crossfades etc. But when I use that new file in the new montage to render all regions / CD tracks, I get the same result as if I did so in the original montage; a tick in the same place, which is indeed visible in RX spectrally in addition to audible playback.
Just another thought, but is that with all plugins removed (not just bypassed) when rendering from the single file montage (remove limitless, dither, src, whatever), you still get the ticks in the regions/tracks renders?

bob99
Senior Member
Posts: 2526
Joined: Fri Jan 07, 2011 2:49 am
Contact:

Re: tricks for eliminating pops on ID starts in montage

Post by bob99 » Wed Aug 21, 2019 6:47 pm

kywoman wrote:
Wed Aug 21, 2019 3:29 pm
I'm not having an issue rendering a single file from a montage with crossfades etc. But when I use that new file in the new montage to render all regions / CD tracks, I get the same result as if I did so in the original montage; a tick in the same place, which is indeed visible in RX spectrally in addition to audible playback.
And these are cd track splice markers (not start and end markers), and the montage verifies ok with the check conformity button? Because if so, I'm with Justin, that should never happen, and I've never experienced it.

kywoman
New Member
Posts: 39
Joined: Tue Mar 15, 2016 3:58 pm
Contact:

Re: tricks for eliminating pops on ID starts in montage

Post by kywoman » Wed Aug 21, 2019 7:02 pm

bob99 wrote:
Wed Aug 21, 2019 6:24 pm
kywoman wrote:
Wed Aug 21, 2019 3:29 pm
I'm not having an issue rendering a single file from a montage with crossfades etc. But when I use that new file in the new montage to render all regions / CD tracks, I get the same result as if I did so in the original montage; a tick in the same place, which is indeed visible in RX spectrally in addition to audible playback.
Just another thought, but is that with all plugins removed (not just bypassed) when rendering from the single file montage (remove limitless, dither, src, whatever), you still get the ticks in the regions/tracks renders?
Correct. It's a 48/32F single file, rendering as individual files 48/32F still get ticks. Nothing in Effects, and everything master section (just SRC and dither), either individually bypassed or render options > bypass master section. All same outcome.

Yes, all splices other than of course very beginning and end of montage. Check conformity won't OK because it's at 48k. But that's never been at issue in past in not getting pops for file sets.

kywoman
New Member
Posts: 39
Joined: Tue Mar 15, 2016 3:58 pm
Contact:

Re: tricks for eliminating pops on ID starts in montage

Post by kywoman » Thu Aug 22, 2019 2:04 am

Here are visual accompaniments:

The splice in WL:
Screen Shot 2019-08-21 at 3.27.34 PM.png
(72.88 KiB) Not downloaded yet
The resultant song/individual file in RX:
Screen Shot 2019-08-21 at 2.46.30 PM.png
(1.64 MiB) Not downloaded yet
After some time testing along with Justin P (providing, as usual, a generous amount of his time), a lot has been ruled out as the culprit/confirmed as to not contribute (e.g., aforementioned resampling), but no clear cause. Neither of us has so far found a way to generate a file set (all songs as individual files) where song 2 or 3 (as shown above) does not have the tick introduced into the file at the end (track 2) /beginning (track 3). In my mind, this is the crux of the issue - ticks should not be introduced into individual tracks upon render with a splice.

Here's an interesting (at least to me) finding:
If rendering the album as a single file, ticks do not get introduced, even if that render is entirely from individual wavs that have the ticks in them at the individual track file starts/ends!

At the risk of sounding like being on a loop, it’s ONLY when rendering into individual tracks that the ticks appear.

Hopefully that furthers the info provided in my earlier posts in getting to the bottom of this. Thankfully the client has some flexibility in the release date, but I still hope to resolve this soon. It's the nicest clients you want to give the highest level of service possible, and then some.

User avatar
Justin P
Senior Member
Posts: 2462
Joined: Fri Aug 12, 2011 12:49 pm
Location: Milwaukee, WI USA
Contact:

Re: tricks for eliminating pops on ID starts in montage

Post by Justin P » Thu Aug 22, 2019 4:12 am

Yeah. What's perplexing is that if you zoom way in on the start of one of the rendered files, you can see something.

But if you line these rendered files up back to back in a montage, and play from one to the other, I don't hear a tick.

And even weirder is if you render a NEW full WAV from these questionable WAVs, there doesn't appear to be any little noise! So weird.

Attached are two screen shots. One is where you can see something at the very start of the file, and the other is of the NEW full render and you would expect to see that same thing at 5:20 but it's not there visually, or audibly.

Whatever this is, I wonder if it's small enough that most pro apps don't have a problem, but consumer apps like iTunes may produce more of a tick at this transition point. I've long since trusted iTunes for perfect gapless playback so I'm not ready to consider it gospel at this time.

It's a strange case.
Attachments
02 Full Montage.png
(377.13 KiB) Not downloaded yet
01 Single WAV.png
(945.72 KiB) Not downloaded yet
https://www.mysteryroommastering.com/https://www.justincarlperkins.com/
https://www.facebook.com/groups/WaveLab/

iMac Pro 3.0GHz 10-Core • 64GB RAM • SSD for OS and audio • MacOS 10.14.6
Mac Mini 3.2 GHz Intel Core i7 (6-Core) • 32GB RAM • SSD for OS and audio • MacOS 10.14.6

RME AES HDSPe, MUTEC MC-3+ Smart Clock USB, Grace m905, Grace m900

bob99
Senior Member
Posts: 2526
Joined: Fri Jan 07, 2011 2:49 am
Contact:

Re: tricks for eliminating pops on ID starts in montage

Post by bob99 » Thu Aug 22, 2019 4:47 am

Justin P wrote:
Thu Aug 22, 2019 4:12 am
Yeah. What's perplexing is that if you zoom way in on the start of one of the rendered files, you can see something.

But if you line these rendered files up back to back in a montage, and play from one to the other, I don't hear a tick.
Is it a pretty steady continuous sound there?

I made a 100 Hz sine wave in a 48K file, put that in a montage and randomly added splice markers. Then rendered through the master section with src to 44.1 cd tracks. At two of the track points I got abberations. The other track points were clean. I can't hear the ticks, but the Izotope picture looks pretty similar to what kywoman posted earlier.
Attachments
Track render 100 Hz in Izotope.PNG
(wavelab render viewed in izotope)
(282.17 KiB) Not downloaded yet
Track render 100 Hz in Wavelab.PNG
(wavelab render viewed in wavelab)
(24.25 KiB) Not downloaded yet
Last edited by bob99 on Thu Aug 22, 2019 7:31 pm, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
Justin P
Senior Member
Posts: 2462
Joined: Fri Aug 12, 2011 12:49 pm
Location: Milwaukee, WI USA
Contact:

Re: tricks for eliminating pops on ID starts in montage

Post by Justin P » Thu Aug 22, 2019 1:55 pm

To help prevent issues, I never run the Resampler on renders, I like to externally SRC and use the Custom Montage Duplicate option so I can't speak to cases where Resampler might be causing an issue.

I still believe that with my workflow, the renders are OK. I don't hear an issue when loading the WAVs of each track into a new montage and playing through the transitions. And if I render a new full WAV from the rendered WAVs of each track (as a dummy check), I still don't hear any issues at the transitions, and those visual concerns at the start/end of files in a spectrogram (RX or WL in orange mode) are not there.

PG did tell me this:

To make it short:
any discontinuity in the audio will cause a discontinuity in the spectrogram.
The start of a file, is a discontinuity between silence and sound.


A couple years ago I remember doing some tests and research and I found iTunes to not be trustworthy to play back gapless WAV files and all bets are off with mp3 and AAC due to the few milliseconds of silence that pads the start of each file.

What I currently think kywoman is experiencing is two non issues:

iTunes can't be trusted for gapless WAV playback
And PG's comment about the discontinuity in the spectrogram.

For project approval, I send clients a DDP w/HOFA DPP Player, and sometimes WAVs of each track so they know where the tracks start, and a reference mp3 of the whole thing as one file to approve the track spacing if the DDP is too hard for them to use. I think this method works for exposing problems, but loading WAVs into iTunes (or any consumer media player) is likely to produce user/software indued errors that aren't really there.

I'm currently going with, if the WAVs sound correct when played back in a new montage to test, and also sound/look correct when rendering a new full test file to inspect, then all is good.

We of course still need to be careful when creating gapless albums but I think my method is capable of that.

I just mastered a 4 CD set for Rhino/Warner and 3 of the 4 disc had some gapless tracks and the WAVs passed their stringent QC department who are more diligent than I would have expected, and that's a good thing.
https://www.mysteryroommastering.com/https://www.justincarlperkins.com/
https://www.facebook.com/groups/WaveLab/

iMac Pro 3.0GHz 10-Core • 64GB RAM • SSD for OS and audio • MacOS 10.14.6
Mac Mini 3.2 GHz Intel Core i7 (6-Core) • 32GB RAM • SSD for OS and audio • MacOS 10.14.6

RME AES HDSPe, MUTEC MC-3+ Smart Clock USB, Grace m905, Grace m900

kywoman
New Member
Posts: 39
Joined: Tue Mar 15, 2016 3:58 pm
Contact:

Re: tricks for eliminating pops on ID starts in montage

Post by kywoman » Thu Aug 22, 2019 4:02 pm

Justin P wrote:
Thu Aug 22, 2019 1:55 pm
To help prevent issues, I never run the Resampler on renders, I like to externally SRC and use the Custom Montage Duplicate option so I can't speak to cases where Resampler might be causing an issue.
SRC has been ruled out as a causal agent. It happens with or without SRC at any point.[/quote]
wrote: I still believe that with my workflow, the renders are OK. I don't hear an issue when loading the WAVs of each track into a new montage and playing through the transitions. And if I render a new full WAV from the rendered WAVs of each track (as a dummy check), I still don't hear any issues at the transitions, and those visual concerns at the start/end of files in a spectrogram (RX or WL in orange mode) are not there.
Single continuous files don't get the tick - I've confirmed and maintained that from the outset with said workflow. What would you do differently on this project for rendering all the songs as a file set?
wrote:PG did tell me this:
To make it short:
any discontinuity in the audio will cause a discontinuity in the spectrogram.
The start of a file, is a discontinuity between silence and sound.
Yup, having that sine wav shown above cut to zero at end of 2, or jump up from zero at beginning (3), as on individually sliced files, is where the issue arises, and why the click appears on the files in a spectral view.

It makes sense to me that when playing the tracks back to back in Wavelab, and indeed, when rendered as a single composite of all tracks, there's no click, because there's no discontinuity there, as shown in the above pic at the sample level - the waves are cresting, but it's just a regular old sine wave with no space between the samples/tracks.

When playing back the individual files forming a new montage, WL seems to be able to ignore the discontinuity introduced at beg.end of files. But no other app will do the same. To wit...
wrote: A couple years ago I remember doing some tests and research and I found iTunes to not be trustworthy to play back gapless WAV files and all bets are off with mp3 and AAC due to the few milliseconds of silence that pads the start of each file.
What I currently think kywoman is experiencing is two non issues:
iTunes can't be trusted for gapless WAV playback
As discussed, it also happens in VLC. Maybe iTunes is untrustworthy for a variety of other reasons, but if invoking that conclusion as the culprit here, then it should follow that VLC or Reaper can't be trusted either! And I think we can both agree that Reaper is a pretty pro app. Put tracks 2 and 3 in a track on Reaper and play back the session - a loud pop!
wrote:I'm currently going with, if the WAVs sound correct when played back in a new montage to test, and also sound/look correct when rendering a new full test file to inspect, then all is good.
...
but loading WAVs into iTunes (or any consumer media player) is likely to produce user/software indued errors that aren't really there.
But you see the ticks! And you hear them! That is problematic.
I don't see how one goes about explaining this to a client - from your statement, it seems I'd have to advise them to not play the files in iTunes or VLC, or anything else that will accurately read the tick that is at the beginning of a file? That they can't play an individual song in these apps without getting a loud pop? Or even play all the files back to back continuously without getting the pop?

Whether we like iTunes or not for other issues is immaterial to this issue, as the issue happens in playback of the files, either at start of the file or through the section of the two files (towards end of track 2, seamlessly playing into track 3) in both VLC and Reaper. And even if iTunes had issues, it's still a dominant playback format that should be considered for end-users. They are going to use it whether we prefer them to or not.
wrote: We of course still need to be careful when creating gapless albums but I think my method is capable of that.
I just mastered a 4 CD set for Rhino/Warner and 3 of the 4 disc had some gapless tracks and the WAVs passed their stringent QC department who are more diligent than I would have expected, and that's a good thing.
I love me some Rhino! This tick introduction is a very infrequent occurrence for myself. I've rendered hundreds of live shows with individual tracks. But it doesn't mean that when it occurs, it should be disregarded. I agree your method is capable of that. A number of workflows are. But what's interesting here is that your workflow was used here! I'm not trying to attack it, I love it. I'm wanting WL to better address these issues, however infrequent they occur.

I really hope there will be some other options / tools for these scenarios. And by that I mean the Feature Request of expansion of the find zero crossing feature, and other tools that would allow people to better address discontinuites at CD Splices, ideally even before QC'ing! Maybe like the CD Conformity check, as an example.

I have to run for today, and maybe there are some ways I could have worded the above bits slightly softer. Here's my disclaimer: with all of the above, I can't stress enough that I am not trying to be snarky or combative. I'm just trying to drill down on the problem. I have nothing but respect for y'all helping out. It never hurts to keep at the forefront there's a big difference between disagreeing with an argument (premises and conclusion) vs. the person!

Post Reply

Return to “WaveLab Pro 9 | WaveLab Elements 9”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests