Page 1 of 1

Export video between locators with replaced audio

Posted: Thu Jul 23, 2015 11:36 pm
by KevinRiepl
This is a feature that I know has been requested before. It would indeed be awesome if it was given some attention.
I have recently (4wks ago) switched over to Cubase from 15yrs with DP, and the one lacking feature that is keeping me from being 100% converted, is the lack of video export.
Yes yes yes, 'Replacing the Audio in a Video File' is an option, but here is why it is not a viable option for film at tv composers. The "Replacing the Audio in Video File" option, replaces the audio in the entire video file from the very start of the video file. When working in film (obviously) you're working with about 20min reels.
If I am in the middle of a REEL, say 1hr into a film and i only need to submit one scene for approval/revisions, I need to be able to export only that scene...not the entire 20min reel.

When writing cues in Digital Performer, I would always export the cue with video.This would allow me to mix the client's 'sound/dialogue' with my cue to be sent off for approval. Clients can watch the scenes anywhere to be able to make notes and then get back to me.

So, an option to be able to "Export video between locators with replaced audio" would be a feature that I am sure would be hugely welcomed by the Cubase community who work in TV and Film. I can't be the only one.

Re: Export video btwn locators w/ replaced audio

Posted: Fri Jul 24, 2015 10:04 am
by TheMaestro
So Obvious !
This is a VIF * ;)


PS: the title would be more pleasing to the eye without abbreviations.

* Very Important Feature

Re: Export video btwn locators w/ replaced audio

Posted: Fri Jul 24, 2015 10:52 am
by MrSoundman
+1

One workaround for this currently is to render a segment of video separately and import that into Cubase, however that adds a time-consuming step prior to beginning work as well as losing the time reference.

As Cubase video handling is done by Quicktime, I suspect the problem here would be that actually cutting the video might require the non-free QuickTime Pro to be installed, and while that additional cost is not likely to be an issue for those who need this function, it would need to be optional for those who don't.

IIRC some years ago Cubase used to use open source libraries for video handling; a return to that would offer a solution for all.

Re: Export video between locators with replaced audio

Posted: Tue Jul 28, 2015 5:31 pm
by KevinRiepl
Wondering if any of the developers at Steinberg hit these forums. Have any of the posts regarding video export been addressed at all? Not trying to be a squeaky wheel here, I am just wondering if I am wasting my time on the boards in hopes that a feature can at least be addressed by them.

Re: Export video between locators with replaced audio

Posted: Tue Jul 28, 2015 6:21 pm
by MrSoundman
Apparently yes, but there's seldom any feedback. It's always worth a bump, and if enough people feel there's a need for it, it will get some attention. If one of the moderators picks up on it and runs with it, it seems to help as well. On the other hand, I do recall waiting years for even simple changes (like batch export!) but then I'm sure it's a matter of priority .... and commercial viability.

Re: Export video between locators with replaced audio

Posted: Tue Jul 28, 2015 6:22 pm
by KevinRiepl
right. makes sense. thnx.

Re: Export video between locators with replaced audio

Posted: Wed Jul 29, 2015 4:30 pm
by MrSoundman
Incidentally, with the release of Windows 10, it appears that QuickTime "cannot be installed on a Windows 10 system which basically removes the video support in Cubase and Nuendo." Fair enough, Steinberg don't yet support Windows 10, but is this not a good reason to ditch QuickTime (which I'm guessing is the limiting factor in not being able to export only the segment between the locators) and instead use a better cross-platform solution (for example ffmpeg)?

Re: Export video between locators with replaced audio

Posted: Thu Aug 06, 2015 4:43 am
by Atardecer
I've been wanting this forever. Well, basically just quicktime export functionality in Cubase as standard. Every other DAW has it. Trimming reels to cue size and replace audio is an incredibly cumbersome method of working when you've got 30 cues to cover and need to send off QT demos.

I believe Steinberg's main response is "buy Nuendo". That's not really good enough considering Cubase is pushed as a composers tool.

Re: Export video between locators with replaced audio

Posted: Thu Aug 06, 2015 10:09 am
by MrSoundman
Atardecer wrote:quicktime export functionality in Cubase as standard
Agreed, except as a feature request I would not be fixating on QuickTime .... what we mean these days is a compatible h.264 or h.265 video file with audio. Packaging it in a QT container would be nice but to make it compatible with QT really only means making it playable by the QT player. On a PC this usually just means renaming the file extension from .mp4 to .mov for example, and even that's not generally necessary, but some houses specify .mov as the deliverable without any understanding of the underlying technology.

I also wouldn't expect Cubase to recode the video; it would be reasonable to expect that it could play back an MPEG or h.264 video video stream, and the "export" function would entail just "smart" cutting of the stream and muxing with the audio, rather than re-rendering. This is all possible with the afore-mentioned open source ffmpeg.

Re: Export video between locators with replaced audio

Posted: Fri Aug 21, 2015 9:41 am
by MrSoundman
Just to note that Apple have released QuickTime 7.7.8 but on the Windows download it still says "for Vista or Windows 7". This is apparently a security fix and there's no claim that it will work or even install on Windows 10.

Perhaps this is a good opportunity for Steinberg to consider removing this dependency on a third party component that is breaking Cubase/Nuendo on Windows in favour of an open source solution such as ffmpeg that offers far greater flexibility and is future-proof?

Re: Export video between locators with replaced audio

Posted: Tue Aug 25, 2015 2:15 pm
by rpaillot805
I agree so much with this feature request.

This is available in Protools, Logic Pro, DP. It's about time to make it in Cubase 8 ;-)

Logic Pro uses Quicktime , as well as Protools. And you dont need the non-free quicktime pro version.
So that should be doable.

Re: Export video between locators with replaced audio

Posted: Sun Sep 06, 2015 8:17 am
by alexkharlamov
Absolutely!! PLEASE, Steinberg, you can't even imagine how much time and efforts this will save us.

Thank you, Steinberg.

Re: Export video between locators with replaced audio

Posted: Sun Sep 06, 2015 10:16 am
by Puma0382
rpaillot805 wrote:I agree so much with this feature request.

This is available in Protools, Logic Pro, DP. It's about time to make it in Cubase 8 ;-)

Logic Pro uses Quicktime , as well as Protools. And you dont need the non-free quicktime pro version.
So that should be doable.
But that's all Apple of course... Steiny would I'm sure prefer ONE cross-platform solution. :-)

I see that the Reaper guys have adopted both VLC and the ffmpeg libraries for their 'video support'. Wonder if there's any truck with that..?

Re: Export video between locators with replaced audio

Posted: Sun Oct 18, 2015 11:57 am
by Giovanni63
This would be a great feature that I' m waiting to see in Cubase. Just cut the video and export it with the replaced audio.Please!

Re: Export video between locators with replaced audio

Posted: Wed Feb 03, 2016 10:34 pm
by tlockett
I can't believe this function is not in Cubase, I've used PTHD for years and it's easy to bounce mixes with the dialog to a QT mov file
Yes,this is a must have feature for anyone scoring music to picture.
Since most of my post audio work is done in PT I haven't notice that CBP can't do this, it can do so many things PT can't.
So does Nuendo,not have a bounce to movie feature? I'd be surprised since it is the post audio flagship product.

Re: Export video between locators with replaced audio

Posted: Wed Mar 16, 2016 3:46 am
by walturbo
YES PLEASE!! Just add video export. When I "replace audio..."the fle never syncs. Come on guys:-))

Re: Export video between locators with replaced audio

Posted: Fri Apr 08, 2016 5:34 pm
by GPnicolett
I also want to pile on here, as I always do, since this feature is SO important and SO basic and SO needed. PLEASE Steinberg consider implementing it.

Re: Export video between locators with replaced audio

Posted: Thu Apr 14, 2016 9:41 pm
by jaslan
I would like to have this feature also. Importing video clips into Cubase and editing them, synchronizing them, etc., all just to watch the video inside of Cubase doesn't really help much. Being able to at least "bounce" the video so one can them add the audio to it would be great. Even better, allow a complete export of video and audio all in one! Now that, I would gladly pay extra for.

Re: Export video between locators with replaced audio

Posted: Fri Apr 15, 2016 12:16 am
by tepa
To what i know, Nuendo don't have it either.
I wish to see this feature in Cubase.

+1 to export cue with video for a simple and regular reason as explained by KevinRiepl.

Re: Export video between locators with replaced audio

Posted: Fri Apr 15, 2016 9:47 am
by MrSoundman
The call to get rid of QuickTime has now become urgent with the news that Apple are no longer supporting QuickTime for Windows and the fact that there are already zero-day exploits out there.

So please, Steinberg, move to ffmpeg and it should make it easy to export video!

Re: Export video between locators with replaced audio

Posted: Fri Apr 15, 2016 7:42 pm
by MrSoundman
(Quote from another thread)
Grim wrote:There is a statement from Steinberg here in case anyone missed it:
http://www.steinberg.net/en/newsandeven ... -3683.html
Hopefully some of that work might include adding an export option .....

Re: Export video between locators with replaced audio

Posted: Tue Nov 22, 2016 12:13 pm
by Gadda
tepa wrote:To what i know, Nuendo don't have it either.
I wish to see this feature in Cubase.

+1 to export cue with video for a simple and regular reason as explained by KevinRiepl.


+1!!!!!!